Ask an Affiliate Manager: Affiliate Marketing in the Age of AI (What’s Dying, What’s Working, and How to Win)

In this Rewardful webinar, Emmet Gibney (CEO, Rewardful) sat down with Ryan Robinson, creator at RyRob.com, co-founder of RightBlogger, and long-time affiliate operator, to unpack how AI is reshaping affiliate marketing, what old playbooks no longer work, and what does drive results now: personality-led video, smaller-but-mightier partner portfolios, and giving affiliates usable “ammo” like templates and free tools.

📺 Watch the full session on YouTube

Meet the Experts

• Emmet Gibney – CEO at Rewardful
• Ryan Robinson – Creator, educator, and co-founder of RightBlogger (50+ AI tools for creators)

What Changed: The Old SEO Playbook Is Fading

“Listicle SEO arbitrage used to be a business model. Today it’s a knife fight—and AI is changing how people discover.” — Ryan Robinson

• AI answers + saturated SERPs reduced the surface area for classic “Top X Tools” posts to rank and convert.
• A few winners per niche dominate; relying solely on SEO listicles is now a fragile strategy.
• Video is ascendant. Audiences want to learn from people, not just skim text snippets.

The New Moat: Personality-Led Content (Especially Video)

• Be real. Audiences have a strong BS detector. People follow creators who teach and entertain.
• Ship weekly video. Short, useful videos travel farther—Ryan sees outsized reach with LinkedIn vertical video versus identical shorts on YouTube.
• Diversify (YouTube, LinkedIn, TikTok, podcasts, webinars). It’s portfolio math: more shots on goal, more at-bats for one to take off.

How SaaS Partnering Is Evolving

• Brands prioritize video (tutorials, live webinars, UGC) over static blog sponsorships.
• Hybrid deals win: smaller upfront + affiliate revshare after a proof-of-fit test.
• Micro > Macro (often). Spreading budget across 10–50 niche creators usually beats one big swing; algorithms now reward content quality, not just follower count.

AI: Where It Actually Helps (and Where It Doesn’t)

✅ Great uses

• Research & ideation: topic clustering, outline drafts, script scaffolds.
• Editing acceleration: trimming dead air, clipping shorts, subtitles/captions.
• Data wrangling: sorting big lists (e.g., LinkedIn exports) to flag likely partners.

⚠️ Proceed with caution

• Fully synthetic “AI influencer” feeds: fleeting spikes, weak trust.
• One-click content farms: volume without authenticity rarely compounds.

A Practical Stack (Mentioned in the Session)

• Editing & clipping: Gling, auto-cut tools; captioning/shorts helpers.
• Voiceover & video augmentation:  ElevenLabs, avatar/video tools (when tastefully used for b-roll or intros).
• Data cleanup & enrichment: Export contacts (e.g., LinkedIn CSV), then use an LLM to categorize and shortlist targets.

Give Affiliates “Ammo”: Free Tools & Templates

Ryan’s high-leverage tactic: embeddable free tools that solve a real micro-problem, then ladder into the paid product.

• Public, niche-specific tools (e.g., “AI article writer,” “hike planner”) act as lead magnets and affiliate landing assets.
• Affiliates can embed these tools on their own content, capturing intent and driving tracked trials.

How to Adapt Your Program (Manager Playbook)

1. Define partner personas‍

List your top 4–5 partner types (YouTuber, LinkedIn educator, newsletter, community, tutorial blogger). For each: audience fit, content format, motivation (fee vs. free product vs. commission), and what you’ll offer (EPC, pages that convert, creative, co-marketing).

2. Recruit like a portfolio manager

• Start with manual, high-touch outreach to 20–50 precise fits.
• Lead with value: a free account/product, your best-converting links, content angles, and a small test budget when applicable.
• Prefer micro-creators with clear topic authority and engaged comments over vanity follower counts.

3. Onboard like product‍

Treat activation as onboarding; the “aha” is first commission.‍

5-day welcome sequence:

1. ‍Welcome + unique link + how to reach you.‍
2. Assets (logos, banners, deep links, screenshots, demo walkthrough).‍
3. What works (top converting pages, sample headlines/CTAs, examples).‍
4. Maximize earnings (promo calendar, exclusive codes, placements, do/don’ts).‍
5. Office hours + Calendly + reminder of perks.

Create a single resource hub (Notion or site): media kit, case studies, competitor comparisons, ad copy examples, tracking/UTM guide, and your contact.

4. Hybrid incentives

• Small fee + commission for creator tests.
• Volume tiers, time-boxed boosts, and exclusive codes.
• Consider buying traffic to a partner’s high-ranking tutorial for your core term (third-party endorsement > brand ad).

5. Let data steer sponsorships‍

Track by partner: clicks, trials, conversion rate, new MRR. Identify the outliers who convert above average, then expand deals (webinars, newsletter placements, deeper content).

For New Affiliates (Creator Playbook)

• Pick a cadence (e.g., one video/week) and stick to it—reps matter more than polish.
• Blend edu + entertainment: tutorials, reactions, teardown walkthroughs.
• Use AI to go faster, not faker: scripting, edits, shorts, captions.
• Build assets: checklists, swipe files, calculators/tools your audience wants.
• Own your list: email remains your compounding channel when algorithms shift.

Common Pitfalls (to avoid)

• Treating recruitment as a one-time task (it’s continuous pipeline work).
• Batching generic AI outreach (humans can smell it).
• Over-indexing on giant creators too early; test 10–50 micros first.
• Launching partners with no assets, no examples, and no point-of-contact.
• Betting the farm on SEO listicles alone.

Audience Pulse Check (Webinar Poll)

• ~50% reported they’re not using AI yet.
• Others primarily use AI for content creation, with some mention of partner discovery and data cleanup.
  Takeaway: there’s still easy advantage for teams who implement AI thoughtfully in research, scripting, and editing.

Key Takeaways

1. Authenticity scales better than AI slop. Video-first, personality-led content wins attention.
2. Portfolio approach > hero bet. Spread tests across niche creators; let data pick your winners.
3. Arm affiliates. Provide tools, templates, and a stacked resource hub.
4. Onboard like PMs. Drive to first commission with a tight 5-day sequence.
5. Use AI for speed, not fakery. Research, scripting, editing—yes. Synthetic “influencers”—mostly no.

Ready to Level Up Your Program?

Run your affiliates, creators, and referrals on Rewardful with tracked links, hybrid payouts, and flexible commissioning.

👉 Start your Rewardufl trial

🎓 New to partnerships? Take our free Affiliate Marketing Course.